“When we say, “That’s not fair,” we are saying to God, “You haven’t distributed things as evenly as I would. Even though I’m a sinful human, I know much more about what is just and right than you.” That’s a dangerous position to be in because we know from Scripture that God is our perfect heavenly Father and to trust ourselves to our own care and our own lordship only spells disaster.”

There is a phrase in our vocabulary that nobody has to teach us to say. It’s a phrase kids learn quickly in childhood. And it’s a phrase you should ban in your household:

“That’s not fair.”

It sounds innocent enough. Everybody wants life to be fair, right? But this is an insidious phrase, revealing a sin so bankrupt it goes back to the beginning—back to the Fall of Man. It’s essentially what Eve was told by the serpent:

“You’re getting a raw deal. You’re entitled to more. God is holding out on you.”

If you read Paul’s account of the Fall in Romans, you’ll discover that it was this attitude—ingratitude and entitlement—that lit the match of sin, plunging Creation into darkness. And it’s a surefire way to test your own heart and find out where the idols are.

Maybe it seems a bit melodramatic to bring all of this up to my four children, but I fear that if I allow them to embed entitlement in their little hearts right now—if their first reaction to a someone else getting an extra dessert, a gift from a friend, a new pair of shoes is “That’s not fair”—then the roots will become more entangled in their hearts as they get older.

So, we don’t allow this in our home. And when it comes up, my kids know they are in for some form of punishment, which usually involves a long-winded soliloquy from Dad that goes something like this:

1. You are right in saying that life isn’t fair.

Because it’s not fair that little children will go to bed hungry tonight, having eaten nothing but a handful of rice, and you’ve just had seconds on french fries.

It’s not fair that some boys and girls grow up without a mother and father, orphaned by a war they didn’t start.

It’s not fair that some children won’t see many birthdays, succumbing to diseases we treat with immunizations and routine trips to the doctor.

So if there is a complaining about being fair, it’s you and me and all of us in prosperous, free America on the other side of “Not fair.” In the line of people complaining about a bad lot in life, we are several zip codes away from the front. Most of the world is pointing to us and saying, “Life isn’t fair,” and they have a much better case.

2. You really don’t want life to be fair.

We all have a scale of what is just, but the problem is that we are human, not God. He actually holds the scale, and the Bible tells us that it’s weighed down heavily in favor of his mercy. Listen to the words of the prophet, Jeremiah, “It is of his mercies we are not consumed” (Lam. 3:22). In other words, because of our sin against him, it is overwhelming mercy that we are not immediate targets of his judgement. Instead, we are beneficiaries of his grace. We really don’t want God to be fair, but to be just.

What’s unfair is Jesus’ assuming our wrath and guilt on the cross on our behalf so we could be restored to a right relationships with God. And on a more personal, pragmatic, earthly level, we should ask ourselves: Do we really want God to even out the score? For us in wealthy, rich America, that might mean taking some things away from us and giving them to the less fortunate. Or someone more appreciative.

3. A heart of ingratitude and entitlement is evident of a deeper problem with God.

This is what worries me most about entitlement. It is saying to God: “I do not trust you to be my Father, to take care of my needs, to love me and care for me.” Worse, it elevates self to a god-like position. Ingratitude says: I know better what is good for me. I’m a better god than God.

When we say, “That’s not fair,” we are saying to God, “You haven’t distributed things as evenly as I would. Even though I’m a sinful human, I know much more about what is just and right than you.” That’s a dangerous position to be in because we know from Scripture that God is our perfect heavenly Father and to trust ourselves to our own care and our own lordship only spells disaster (Prov.14:12; Matt. 7:9-11). You don’t want to go through life as your own lord, your own god or your own master. You only have to look around at the misery and despair in the world to see that’s not a path worth pursuing.

Read More