Note the anthropomorphizing of God:  Why doesn’t He do what we are supposed to do?  But what if God is not a kind person like us looking down from the sky, but a being who is qualitatively different than we are, completely “other” than ourselves?  What if God does not just hand down rules for our and His behavior, but rather, is the source of everything that is good, underlying the very fabric of the moral order? 

I first heard the phrase from a radical feminist:  If God punished His Son for our sins, that would be “cosmic child abuse.”  Since then, I have been hearing it more and more, including from evangelicals!  But to think of the atonement in that way demonstrates a profound misunderstanding of the triune God and the deity of Christ.

Here are some comments from Rev. Steve Chalke, a Baptist and a leader of the U.K.’s progressive evangelicals.  From Christian Today,Traditional view of atonement ‘cheapens God’s forgiveness’ says Steve Chalke:

Chalke, who leads Oasis Church Waterloo as well as heading up the community change charity, has previously described the doctrine – assumed by many evangelicals – that God punished Jesus on the cross instead of us as ‘cosmic child abuse’.

In his latest video, he says PSA removes God’s ability to forgive.

He says: ‘Why can’t God do what he asks us to be able to do; to freely forgive without demanding punishment first?’. . . .

“If God needs someone to “pay the price” for our sin, the question is does he ever really forgive anyone at all? Stop and think about it for a moment. If you owed someone a hundred pounds and they held you to it – refused to release you from the debt – unless or until someone else paid your bill for you, in what sense did they forgive your debt at all?’

Note the anthropomorphizing of God:  Why doesn’t He do what we are supposed to do?  But what if God is not a kind person like us looking down from the sky, but a being who is qualitatively different than we are, completely “other” than ourselves?  What if God does not just hand down rules for our and His behavior, but rather, is the source of everything that is good, underlying the very fabric of the moral order?  So that when we violate that moral order, we are in conflict with God and our very creation, to our ruination?   And what if, this God, unfathomably, as part of this same goodness that we violate, loves us anyway?  And that He resolves this contradiction by becoming one of us and, somehow, taking into Himself our sins and their consequences, imparting to us His goodness in exchange?

Read More