“The Second Commandment trains us for discipleship. In a world that tells us to invent our own reality, God calls us to live within His revealed structure. That’s not bondage—it’s freedom. He hasn’t left us to grope in the dark, hoping we stumble upon Him. He’s promised: ‘I will meet you in Word, sacrament, and prayer.’ And that is more than enough.”

Scene: A quiet corner in a local coffeehouse. Mr. and Mrs. Smith, longtime members of a nearby megachurch, have recently embraced the five points of Calvinism. They’re eager to visit a Reformed congregation but carry serious questions about the Second Commandment. Mrs. Smith, with tears in her eyes, confesses that God used The Passion of the Christ to bring her to faith. With warm patience, Dr. Harrison Perkins sits across from them, coffee mug in hand, ready to listen and shepherd them with Scripture and the Reformed confessions.

Q1. The Commandment Itself

Mr. Smith: “Dr. Perkins, how do we actually define the Second Commandment for Christians today? Is it only about idolatrous worship, or does it also address making and using images of Christ?”

Dr. Perkins: The commandment does more than forbid bowing to idols. It regulates how we approach God at all. That’s why the Reformed tradition connects it to the regulative principle: in worship we only do what God has commanded. When it comes to Christ, there’s no neutral ground. In Scripture, whenever people truly recognize Him, they worship. So an image of Christ isn’t a help—it’s a cruel obstacle. It shows the Savior but demands that we withhold worship.

Q2. The Heidelberg Witness

Mr. Smith: “The Heidelberg Catechism (Q. 98) says images are not to be ‘taught or tolerated in the churches.’ How should we understand that today, especially with children’s Bibles or Christmas plays?”

Dr. Perkins: The Heidelberg is clear because images always reshape our view of God. Even if we feel helped by them, God says they harm us. Think of Eden: the serpent’s lie was that God withholds good from us. To say, “I know images are forbidden, but they help me,” is to fall for that lie. God commands this for our good.

Q3. The Incarnation Question

Mrs. Smith: “But Jesus truly came in the flesh. Doesn’t forbidding images make Him seem less human?”

Dr. Perkins: Not at all. For the disciples, seeing Jesus wasn’t sinful—it was God’s gift in history. But for us to recreate Him is presumption. The Second Commandment doesn’t forbid sight of God when He gives it; it forbids us from demanding sight on our own terms. Christ’s humanity is not diminished when we obey Him—it’s honored, because we wait for the day when “they shall see his face” (Rev. 22:4).

Q4. Memory and Mental Images

Mr. Smith: “Was it sinful for Mary and the apostles to remember His face? And what about when Christians picture Jesus on the cross while praying?”

Dr. Perkins: Memory is not the same as invention. The apostles remembered because they had truly seen. But when we picture Christ, we speculate. That’s not faith—it’s imagination. And while weakness is real, weakness isn’t permission. The Christian life is full of training ourselves to trust God’s appointed means rather than our mental reconstructions.

Q5. The Camera Test

Mr. Smith: “If cameras had existed in the first century, would it have been sinful to possess a photo of Jesus? How is that different from a painting?”

Dr. Perkins: Seeing Christ in person was never sin—the disciples did! But God, in His providence, chose not to let cameras exist then. That tells us something. Any painting or sculpture today is not Christ but speculation. And that’s not just a Second Commandment violation; it’s a Ninth Commandment violation too. To present a false picture and say, “This is Jesus,” is bearing false witness.

Q6. Public vs. Private

Mr. Smith: “What about images at home? A picture of Jesus passed down from my grandmother—it’s sentimental, not worship.”

Dr. Perkins: Scripture doesn’t draw a line between public and private. Jacob had to bury his family idols (Gen. 35). Sometimes faithfulness means giving up cherished things. That’s hard. But when God gave His Son for us, even the most sentimental attachments pale in comparison.

Q7. Children’s Bibles & Sunday School

Mrs. Smith: “If I read a picture Bible with my kids and it has cartoon pictures of Jesus, am I sinning?”

Dr. Perkins: We should be gentle with parents here, but clear: Heidelberg 98 applies. The best way to teach children Christ’s humanity is not through drawings, but through the Word preached and sacraments seen. We don’t need sketches to show He became flesh—we need God’s appointed means to grow their faith.

Q8. Christmas Traditions

Mr. Smith: “Is it wrong to put out a nativity with baby Jesus? What if it’s faceless cutouts outlined in Christmas lights?”

Dr. Perkins: Depicting the Godhead is off-limits. A manger with hay? Fine. Silhouettes of Mary or Joseph? Fine. But a figure meant to be Christ, even if hidden, crosses the line.

At our house, we even once received a nativity made of decorated cookies—including one meant to be Jesus. We destroyed it by eating it. Better to enjoy cookies than to keep an idol.

Q9. Evangelistic Films

Mrs. Smith (tearfully): “I was saved after watching The Passion of the Christ. How can you say that was sinful when God used it?”

Dr. Perkins: I would never deny God’s providence. He uses crooked sticks to draw straight lines. But that doesn’t justify the stick. People have even claimed adultery made them feel closer to God. That’s delusion. God saved you despite the medium, not because of it. Now the call is to walk by faith, not by images.

Q10. Golden Calf and Family Photos

Mr. Smith: “If humans are the image of God, why can I take photos of my family but not of Jesus? And what about the golden calf—wasn’t that more First Commandment than Second?”

Dr. Perkins: The difference is crucial. Your family bears God’s image, but they are not divine. Christ alone is “the image of the invisible God” (Col. 1:15). To portray Him falsely is to lie about Him.

As for the golden calf, Exodus 32 tells us Israel intended it to represent Yahweh—“These are your gods, O Israel, who brought you up out of Egypt.” They weren’t abandoning the true God for Baal; they were trying to worship the true God with a manmade image. That’s not primarily a First Commandment violation—it’s a Second Commandment violation. They wanted God on their terms, in visible form. That’s exactly what the commandment forbids.

Q11. Images in Devotion

Mrs. Smith (softly): “Sometimes I close my eyes and picture Him when I pray. Is that idolatry?”

Dr. Perkins: Weakness isn’t license. Stray thoughts come to us all. But to cherish those images, to treat them as aids to devotion, is dangerous.

Read More