The Aquila Report

Your independent source for news and commentary from and about conservative, orthodox evangelicals in the Reformed and Presbyterian family of churches

Providence College
  • Biblical
    and Theological
  • Churches
    and Ministries
  • People
    in the News
  • World
    and Life News
  • Lifestyle
    and Reviews
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Music
  • Opinion
    and Commentary
  • General Assembly
    and Synod Reports
    • ARP General Synod
    • EPC General Assembly
    • OPC General Assembly
    • PCA General Assembly
    • PCUSA General Assembly
    • RPCNA Synod
    • URCNA Synod
  • Subscribe
    to Weekly Email
  • Biblical
    and Theological
  • Churches
    and Ministries
  • People
    in the News
  • World
    and Life News
  • Lifestyle
    and Reviews
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Music
  • Opinion
    and Commentary
  • General Assembly
    and Synod Reports
    • ARP General Synod
    • EPC General Assembly
    • OPC General Assembly
    • PCA General Assembly
    • PCUSA General Assembly
    • RPCNA Synod
    • URCNA Synod
  • Subscribe
    to Weekly Email
  • Search
Home/Featured/How David Brooks, Peter Wehner and Others Fail to Address Evangelical Divisions

How David Brooks, Peter Wehner and Others Fail to Address Evangelical Divisions

Some recent careful articles have tried to analyze and illuminate this breakdown, but they are often one-sided, which means that they may simply exacerbate the very tensions they lament.

Written by Paul Marshall | Tuesday, March 22, 2022

There is nothing to be gained and much to be lost by treating those with whom we differ as if they were tribal objects in a quasi-anthropological investigation. Are those who differ from us merely stupid, or perhaps venal, or even evil? Were they simply dropped on their heads as infants? Or do they have something to say to us?

 

The American evangelical world is divided, but being divided is almost its normal state. Yet what perhaps is new is the depth of ruptures and animosities it has engendered. Some recent careful articles have tried to analyze and illuminate this breakdown, but they are often one-sided, which means that they may simply exacerbate the very tensions they lament.

In a much-discussed New York Times article, “The Dissenters Trying to Save Evangelicalism From Itself,” David Brooks suggests the analogy of 12 old, close friends and imagines the situation of one side: “If six of those people suddenly took a political or public position you found utterly vile…(and) those six people think that your position is utterly vile. You…had actually been total strangers all along.”

Brooks suggests this illustrates what has happened to American Christians, especially evangelicals. This divide is very much more than simply pro- or anti-Trump positions, although this can function as a handy shorthand, since support for Trump may have revealed the cleavages that were already there.

He chooses several people he describes as wanting to save evangelicalism from its frailties and failures — from itself. However, the people he interviews — such as Russell Moore, Tim Dalrymple and Kristin Kobes Du Mez — largely represent only one side of the division. We are told about but do not hear from their separated brethren, such as Al Mohler or Robert Jeffress, who might also have something to say from their opposite side of this gulf. Might they have correctly anticipated some of the perils and failures that have arisen with the Biden presidency? Sadly, they appear not as discussants but as objects of discussion, like Prufrock, “formulated, sprawling on a pin.”

An earlier important article by Peter Wehner in the Atlantic, “The Evangelical Church Is Breaking Apart,” addressed these same divisions in a similar manner. His range of interviewees was wider than Brooks’ and included several of my friends and others I admire. Still, it didn’t include people from the 80% of White evangelicals who supported Trump.

Both articles are like reading a description of a marital breakup that quotes only one of the broken parties.

Read More

Related Posts:

  • The Shattering of Evangelicalism
  • Joe Biden Misreads Augustine
  • John Newton’s Guidance for our Social Media Age
  • The "Young, Restless, Reformed" Movement Wasn’t Enough, but…
  • A New Sin, and a New Salvation Requirement?

Subscribe, Follow, Listen

  • email-alt
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • apple-podcasts
  • anchor
Providence College
Belhaven University

Archives

Books

Special

God is Holy
  • About
  • Advertise Here
  • Contact Us
  • Donations
  • Email Alerts
  • Leadership
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Principles and Practices
  • Privacy Policy

Important:

Free Subscription

Aquila Report Email Alerts

Special

Letter of Jude
  • About
  • Advertise Here
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Principles and Practices
  • RSS Feed
  • Subscribe to Weekly Email Alerts
Providence Christian College - visit

DISCLAIMER: The Aquila Report is a news and information resource. We welcome commentary from readers; for more information visit our Letters to the Editor link. All our content, including commentary and opinion, is intended to be information for our readers and does not necessarily indicate an endorsement by The Aquila Report or its governing board. In order to provide this website free of charge to our readers,  Aquila Report uses a combination of donations, advertisements and affiliate marketing links to  pay its operating costs.

Return to top of page

Website design by Five More Talents · Copyright © 2023 The Aquila Report · Log in