Perhaps the most inspiring story of this “New Theism,” is that of Ayaan Hirsi Ali, who came to a powerful belief in Jesus Christ after rejecting Islam (a different theism) and atheism. Now, by Ali’s own admission, she is truly free in Christ. Her story is told in the film Truth Rising, with an even fuller account told in the new Truth Rising Study…There is good reason to hope that a New Theism is emerging and signaling a renewed openness to religion in American life.

Not that long ago, a collection of voices such as Sam Harris, Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, and Ayaan Hirsi Ali loudly proclaimed that God is a delusion and religion a poison. However, in a recent essay for the Claremont Review of Books, Matthew Schmitz argued that the New Atheism—which surged after 9/11 and decried religion as the source of conflict and cultural decline—has largely run its course. In its place, he contended, is a New Theism. 

Schmitz highlighted two 2025 books as evidence. Ross Douthat’s Believe: Why Everyone Should Be Religious argues that faith is both plausible and personally necessary. Jonathan Rauch’s Cross Purposes: Christianity’s Broken Bargain with Democracy defends religion’s social utility in sustaining liberal democracy. To that list could be added Charles Murray’s Taking Religion Seriously, which offers an empirical case for religion’s significance, and Rod Dreher’s Living in Wonder, which argues for the re-enchantment of secular society. 

Taken together, these works represent an emerging theism which, though currently elite-driven, could have a broader cultural influence. The critical next question, of course, is which God are we talking about here? Dabbling with theism is not the same as encountering Yahweh, the God who actually exists.  

C.S. Lewis once described his shock of encountering a living God after dabbling in vague spirituality: 

But God Himself, alive, pulling at the other end of the cord . . . that is quite another matter.

Read More