The damage done to clear thinking by pretending that batteries of questions of this sort adequately assess emotional states cannot be underestimated. The authors gave no indication of having considered religious or philosophical explanations. Yet the lead researcher could confidently declare that “homophobia” is a “disease,” and one “associated with potentially severe psychopathologies.” This is not science. It is either shameless advocacy, sloppy thinking, or both.

So now “homophobia” is being called a “mental disorder,” where “homophobia” is defined in part as holding to the traditional, natural law and religious understanding of same-sex attraction and acts.

A new paper by Giacomo Ciocca and others was picked up by the press and announced with the headline “New Study Suggests Connections Between Homophobia And Mental Disorders.”

The press report opened, “Homosexuality was long derided as a mental disorder, but a new study suggests that it might be more likely that it’s actually homophobia that is a sign of mental disorder.” The article quoted one of the study authors, E.A. Jannini, as saying, “After discussing for centuries if homosexuality is to be considered a disease, for the first time we demonstrated that the real disease to be cured is homophobia, associated with potentially severe psychopathologies.”

Potentially severe psychopathologies? Sounds like the sort of thing that requires treatment, perhaps even against the will of the patients.

This study asked a few hundred Italian students questions from something called the “Homophobia Scale” and from the Symptom Check List-90-R (SCL-90-R), “one of the most widely used self-report psychometric tests in the area of psychopathologic symptom assessment,” which provides nine indexes or scores. One is “psychoticism.” This disorder, the authors tell us, “characterizes many aspects of human thought, but its delineation in a clinical setting pertains to, above all, severe psychopathologic conditions, such as delusion, isolation and interpersonal alienation, but also hostility and anger.”

There’s that “severe” again.

A crude statistical model was created from the quantified answers, with results that claimed “homophobia” was associated with a “significant predictive value of psychoticism.” It all sounds very scientific.

Italy is, of course, largely a Catholic country; indeed, 75% of the respondents identified as Catholic. Faithful Catholics are obliged to hold, and many do hold, natural law views of same-sex attraction, which consider homosexual acts as unnatural, sinful and harmful, or (as the official catechism has it) “objectively disordered.” At the same time, while homosexual acts are condemned in the Bible, orthdoox Catholics — along with orthodox Christians generally — are taught to “love the sinner, hate the sin.” These views are central Christian teachings.

Read More