Presbyterians were founding congregations in the New World as early as the 1630s.  Denton himself had established “a Presbyterian church” in Hempstead, Long Island in 1641 even though he was preaching “to a Presbyterian congregation from the first arrival, in 1630.”   Pre-1700s Presbyterianism in America is shrouded in mystique. Some would say it didn’t … Continue reading The Arrival of American Presbyterianism: We’ve Been Dating It All Wrong